(212)729-9494
New York, NY
(212)729-9494
New York, NY

PRESS RELEASE: JURY ACQUITS ON ALL CHARGES ON THE COLONIAL RAPE CASE

New York City skyline at night
Share on Facebook
Share on X
Share on LinkedIn
By Elena Fast
Criminal defense attorney and former Kings County felony prosecutor

COMPLAINANT TESTIFIES THAT PROSECUTOR INSTRUCTED HER TO DELETE EVIDENCE

ON FEBRUARY 22, 2022, THE BROOME COUNTY DISTRICT ATTORNEY’S OFFICE MADE AN UNFOUNDED AND LEGALLY UNSUPPORTABLE DECISION TO ARREST YARON KWELLER AND JORDAN RINDGEN FOR SEXUAL ASSAULT ALLEGATIONS.  THE BROOME COUNTY DISTRICT ATTORNEY’S DECIDED TO ARREST MR. KWELLER AND MR. RINDGEN DESPITE THERE BEING NO EVIDENCE THAT ANY CRIME HAD OCCURRED. THERE WAS ALSO SUBSTANTIAL EVIDENCE THAT THE COMPLAINANTS HAD IMPROPER FINANCIAL MOTIVES FOR MAKING THEIR CLAIMS.  FROM DAY 1, MR. KWELLER AND MR. RINDGEN VIGOROUSLY MAINTAINED THEIR INNOCENCE. 

ON OCTOBER 31, 2023, JUSTICE PREVAILED AND A JURY RETURNED A VERDICT OF NOT GUILTY ON ALL COUNTS IN LESS THAN TWO HOURS OF DELIBERATIONS. WE ARE ETERNALLY GRATEFUL TO EACH AND EVERY JUROR FOR HONORING THEIR OATH AND FOLLOWING JUDGE COCCHIOLA’S LEGAL INSTRUCTIONS. 

DESPITE THEIR ETHICAL AND LEGAL OBLIGATIONS, THE BROOME COUNTY DISTRICT ATTORNEY’S OFFICE SOUGHT A CONVICTION OF INNOCENT MEN AT ALL COSTS. TRIAL TESTIMONY AND EVIDENCE REVEALED NUMEROUS EXAMPLES OF SHOCKING PROSECUTORIAL MISCONDUCT INCLUDING:  

  • SENIOR ASSISTANT DISTRICT ATTORNEY ALYSSA CONGDON AND THE BROOME COUNTY DISTRICT ATTORNEY’S OFFICE INSTRUCTED A COMPLAINANT TO “DELETE” HER SOCIAL MEDIA ACCOUNTS. 
  • SENIOR ADA CONGDON WITHHELD ONE OF THE COMPLAINANT’S TEXT MESSAGES THAT STATED THAT THE ALLEGED ENCOUNTER WAS CONSENSUAL UNTIL MONTHS AFTER THE GRAND JURY RETURNED AN INDICTMENT. 
  • THE BROOME COUNTY DISTRICT ATTORNEY’S OFFICE FAILED TO PRESERVE AN HOUR AND A HALF OF FAVORABLE BODY WORN CAMERA FOOTAGE OF A RESPONDING TROOPER. PRIOR TO ITS DELETION, THE DEFENSE HAD REQUESTED THAT THE DISTRICT ATTORNEY’S OFFICE PRESERVE AND DISCLOSE THIS EVIDENCE.

“OUR CLIENTS ARE RELIEVED THAT AFTER A TWO YEAR BATTLE, THEY CAN BEGIN TO REBUILD THEIR LIVES AND LIVELIHOOD, WHICH WERE DESTROYED BY THIS MALICIOUS PROSECUTION.” SAID ELENA FAST, ATTORNEY FOR YARON KWELLER. 

MR. KWELLER WAS REPRESENTED BY ELENA FAST, ESQ. OF THE FAST LAW FIRM, P.C. AND PAUL BATTISTI, ESQ. OF THE BATTISTI LAW OFFICES, P.C. MR. RINDGEN WAS REPRESENTED BY THOMAS JACKSON OF JACKSON BERGMAN LLP. THE CASE WAS PROSECUTED BY SENIOR ASSISTANT DISTRICT ATTORNEY ALYSSA CONGDON AND SENIOR ASSISTANT DISTRICT ATTORNEY AMANDA CRONIN (NEE CHAFFE) UNDER THE SUPERVISION OF LUCAS FINLEY, CHIEF ASSISTANT DISTRICT ATTORNEY AND DISTRICT ATTORNEY MICHAEL KORCHAK. 

About the Author

Elena Fast is a New York criminal defense attorney and the Founding and Managing Partner of The Fast Law Firm, P.C. She spent six years as a felony prosecutor at the Kings County District Attorney’s Office, has tried more than 25 federal and state cases to verdict as lead counsel, and has made more than 200 grand jury presentations. She is admitted in New York, New Jersey, the U.S. Supreme Court, four federal circuit courts of appeals, and federal district courts in New York, New Jersey, Connecticut, Illinois, and Texas. She is fluent in Russian. Read her full bio.

Website developed in accordance with Web Content Accessibility Guidelines 2.2.
If you encounter any issues while using this site, please contact us: (212)729-9494
(212)729-9494
New York, NY
(212)729-9494
New York, NY